Posted on

Christopher Columbus: American Icon?

Julia Shaw / October 09, 2012

Columbus Day is an unusual American holiday. It doesn’t commemorate a President or a great American statesman. Christopher Columbus found North America, but he didn’t find, or found, the United States.

As Columbus Day rolled around this year, President Obama tried to subtly change the focus of the holiday. Rather than simply celebrate a daring explorer, he also wanted to spotlight the “indigenous peoples who had inhabited the Western hemisphere for millennia.” His presidential proclamation invited Americans to “reflect on the tragic burdens tribal communities bore in the years that followed [Columbus’s landing]…[and to] commemorate the many contributions they have made to the American experience, and let us continue to strengthen the ties that bind us today.”

But this misses the significance of why America celebrates Columbus Day.

Leon Kass, Amy Kass, and Diana Schuab provide a thorough overview of the history and tradition of Columbus Day in their curriculum, What So Proudly We Hail. Columbus was indeed an important figure for many immigrant communities. More than that, Christopher Columbus has long been an American icon.

“The association between Columbus and America continued to prosper as the revolutionary colonists sought to distance themselves from England,” the curriculum observes. “In Columbus, they found a hero who had challenged the unknown sea, leaving the Old World for a new beginning on a virgin continent—much as they were attempting to do.” By the late 18th century, Americans saw Columbus as “a mythic founding figure.” In the 19th century, he was seen as an “archetype of the American ideal: bold, adventurous, innovative.”

No one captures this better than Ronald Reagan. In a 1988 presidential proclamation, Reagan commemorates Columbus for his spirit: “He was a dreamer, a man of vision and courage, a man filled with hope for the future and with the determination to cast off for the unknown and sail into uncharted seas for the joy of finding whatever was there. Put it all together and you might say that Columbus was the inventor of the American dream.”

Far from a day to remember our divisions or to dwell on past wrongs, Columbus Day is a day to celebrate an American dream that values diversity, yes, but also rewards daring risk-takers. Or as Reagan put it, “not only an intrepid searcher but the dreams and opportunities that brought so many here after him.”


7 thoughts on “Christopher Columbus: American Icon?

  1. At this point it is tradition. We can find fault with anyone.

  2. Oct 9th, Leif Ericksson day nm

  3. Don’t pick on my Italian friend, I still put my Flag up on this day.

  4. Photos of Columbus Day Floats and Church dignitaries on the way. Perhaps you can expand the Topic a little.

  5. Bashing Columbus is more PC bullshit – tearing down truly great people and proping up false heros.

  6. For those of you who feel that we should not celebrate Columbus Day, you should leave this country and return all property that you have to “native” americans (wait, why are they “native” didn’t they come from somewhere else too) as you exit the country. The rest of us appreciate the fact that Columbus opened the door for Europeans to come to this new land and eventually create the greatest country the world has ever known (the Vikings’s voyages did not open the door). You can find fault with just about every person who ever lived. Without Columbus’s voyages what would the world look like today? Who would have control over the area we now call the United States? To regret Columbus is to regret America and while neither Columbus nor America is perfect, I regret the existence of neither.

  7. Not for nothing – why are “Native Americans called native “Americans”?

    How ironically arrogant – forcing the generalized label of “American” on the native people and wiping out (and diminishing) their self-provided names and identities (Cherokee, etc.)

    And WHY did we do this?

    Oh right – it was to honor them and “right the wrong” of calling them “Indians” — you know, correcting the wrong of forcing the generalized label of “Indian” on the native people and wiping out (and diminishing) their self-provided names and identities

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.