A College Degree Used to Guarantee a Job—Not Anymore
the staff of the Ridgewood blog
Ridgewood NJ, for decades, a college degree was considered a golden ticket to success. But for the Class of 2025, that ticket is starting to look more like a scratch-off with no prize. New college graduates are entering a workforce marked by layoffs, automation, hiring freezes, and growing disillusionment — even among those who land jobs.
📉 Unemployment for New Grads Hits 5.8% — The Highest in Four Years
According to March 2025 data from the New York Federal Reserve, the unemployment rate for recent college graduates aged 22–27 has climbed to 5.8%, marking the highest level since 2021. That’s 1.5 times higher than the general unemployment rate — a stunning reversal of the long-standing norm where degree-holders consistently fared better than the average American worker.
For generations, earning a bachelor’s degree meant higher earnings, job stability, and faster access to white-collar careers. But now? Many graduates are struggling to get even a first-round interview.
🤖 Is AI to Blame for the Hiring Drop-Off?
One of the biggest factors fueling this downturn: artificial intelligence. As companies race to automate routine tasks, the once-vital entry-level jobs that helped launch careers are vanishing. From marketing assistants to junior analysts, jobs that once relied on fresh college talent are being replaced — or absorbed — by AI-driven tools.
Even HR departments, often staffed by recent grads themselves, are using algorithms to scan résumés and screen out candidates before a human ever reads their name.
😓 When Grads Do Get Jobs, They’re Not Happy
It’s not just about getting hired — it’s also about what happens after. A growing number of graduates say they feel underemployed, stuck in roles that don’t require a degree or fail to offer meaningful career growth.
Low pay, lack of mentorship, burnout, and the looming pressure of student loan debt are all contributing to a growing sense of post-grad regret.
📊 What the Data Shows: A Snapshot of the Struggle
-
5.8% unemployment rate for recent grads (NY Fed, March 2025)
-
Higher than the general U.S. unemployment rate (~3.8%)
-
Fewer entry-level job listings across finance, tech, media, and law
-
AI replacing entry-level roles once used to train young professionals
📚 A Changing Value Proposition for Higher Education
As economic uncertainty persists, more young people are questioning the return on investment for a college degree. While higher education still offers long-term financial and career benefits, the short-term payoff is no longer guaranteed.
🔍 Looking Ahead: What Can Grads Do?
-
Build in-demand skills like data analysis, AI literacy, and project management
-
Leverage internships and side projects to stand out in a crowded field
-
Consider freelance, contract, or remote work as stepping stones
-
Stay flexible — career paths are no longer linear
🎓 Final Thought: Degrees Still Matter, But the Landscape Has Shifted
A college degree is no longer a magic key to the American dream. For the Class of 2025, it’s a credential that needs to be paired with adaptability, networking, and tech-savviness. The job market may be degrading, but the grads who evolve fastest will be best positioned to thrive.
Gusto is a payroll and HR software that helps you pay your team, file taxes, offer benefits, and more. See how Gusto compares to other providers, get a free trial, and learn how to switch to Gusto in minutes.
https://gusto.com/i/james3539
