July 2,2016
the staff of the Ridgewood blog
Ridgewood NJ, The Ridgewood blog consulted Ridgewood Attorney John Hersperger on the judges “90 days to clear way for Valley Hospital expansion”, and this is a verbatim quote:
“I completely expected this. I attended most of the hearings, and it was clear from the start that the Judge was convinced that the public interest outweighed Ridgewood’s interest, and she was going to contort the law and the facts to support Valley’s expansion. I won’t expound on this now, but with respect to the law, the cases the Judge cites do not back up her reasoning, and in fact, would support the Village’s right to zone the property as the Village sees fit. On the facts, respectfully, she cherry-picked what she needed and ignored decades of evidence clearly indicating that the Village never wanted a giant hospital at the site.
What was perhaps most disappointing was Judge’s remark (paraphrased) from the bench, in which she described that last decade of Valley’s applications as a “saga” for Valley, but just “history” for Ridgewood. Clearly, the judge saw the Village as the bad guys in this case . Honestly, after 60 or so public hearings and all the time and stress that residents endured, it was most painful to hear that kind of comment from a presiding Judge of this County.
So consider this, over the course of decades, Ridgewood has accommodated Valley’s multiple expansions (except for this last one), which has allowed Valley to grow and become one of the busiest and most profitable hospitals in the state. And when we finally say “no”, we’re the bad guys. And consider further we’re saying “no” to an expansion that would more than double the size of the facility. I’d say that contrary to the Judge’s ruling, Valley and the region actually owe Ridgewood a big “thank you” for being the municipality that took the brunt of Valley’s growth for all these years. I agree with the Judge that Valley serves a regional public need. But the delivery of that regional service, on our small local roadways, in a confined residential neighborhood, next to a middle school, should no longer be the sole obligation of Ridgewood. It’s time for a truly regional location for Valley, such as the 26.5 acres they own in Paramus, right between the Garden State Parkway and Route 17.”
So did Herspberger say what our best next move should be?
You would have thought this judge would have asked the very obvious question of Valley as to why they would not consider building on the Paramus site. Ignore one of the more convenient and obvious options to continue serving the regional need ? Really ?
Yea, Really.
Valley was here long before you were and just because you were foolish enough to buy a home with a VERY LARGE HOSPITAL in the distance the greater good should suffer because you made a boneheaded purchase?
This continued nonsense about moving and confined streets is a joke as well. Enough. And that’s exactly what the judge has ruled. Cooler heads prevailed and now we will be afforded the first class hospital we deserve.
It’s not over yet
Yeah we all in Ridgewood made boneheaded purchases. That’s offensive.
I believe we should refuse to lose this fight against yet another major hospital in this area. There are plenty.
yes you said the garage was a done deal ,this is far from over , and Valley doubled in size means double the tax rate for the Village
It’s over. Put a fork in it.
yes like the garage
Where are we on challenging Valley’s “not for profit” status? Seems like that should be at the top of the agenda given the amount Valley owes in back taxes and annual property taxes would allow this Council to finally reduce property taxes. We have a slam dunk case.
3:50- My “boneheaded purchase,” which happens to be closer to Sommerville than Valley, is worth about six times what I purchased it for 35 years ago. But even if I did live near that VERY LARGE HOSPITAL, the fact of the matter is that the last time Valley sought to ” improve,” the housing prices around the hospital actually went up after they announced their plans. Why ? Well, at least some of them were doctors/investors who saw both the short (as in rental) and long term value (as in once completed) of buying there.
By the way, are you telling me that we have not had a “first class hospital ” all along ? Gee, they certainly have had a lot of people living here fooled, including you.